Tuesday, October 2, 2007

How Toys Teach Gender



Toys occupy a central role in the life of children, as everyone remembers from their childhood. What goes by unnoticed is how toys teach children to behave in a certain way and conform to certain social standards. Thus the first thing I noticed when I logged onto the Toys section of amazon.com was that I was immediately given a choice between going to the girl's section and the boy's section. Clearly there is a difference between the messages sent to boys and girls through the toys that are marketed to them. Upon further inspection I noticed a certain pattern to the types of toys that were being suggested for a nine year old girl (or 8 to 11 year old girls, as Amazon has them grouped). The ideological message sent by these toys was one that confirmed certain stereotypes about girls while leaving little room for differentiation from this trend.



The first thing I noticed about the girl's section of Amazon's toy website is that roughly 75% of what I saw was either pink or purple. I reflected on the fact that if I were to visit the boy's section of the website I would not find anything in pink or purple. These colors are used to differentiate between the two genders at a young age, often right at birth. No doubt many girls like these colors. But do girls like these colors because they have a genuine attraction to them or because everything marketed towards girls from the time they are born comes in pink and purple? Stuart Hall explains that "Ideologies tend to disappear from view into the taken-for-granted 'naturalized' world of common sense" (90). Thus, though it seems natural for everything marketed to girls to be in pink, it only appears that way because of a certain gender ideology. A study of girl's toys shows that this ideology is ingrained in children at a very young age.



Upon closer inspection of the individual toys on the page I was viewing, it became apparent that many toys were based around the concept of being able to alter the outfit or hairstyle of either a doll, computerized image, or in the case of a new Barbie product, a combination doll/MP3 player (pictured above with some of the accessories. This product came in a number of outfit colors but the basic idea was the same). By the age of nine, girls are already being taught that choosing hair and clothing styles (in other words, their appearance) is an important part of being a girl. Another series of toys that seemed to be popular are a series of hand-held electronics called Pixel Chix. Essentially a stripped-down version of The Sims, young girls control their character in a variety of different environments which are sold separately but can be combined to create a small interactive world. The scenarios offered were a house, a car, babysitting for the neighbors, and the mall (with four stores: salon, pet shop, food court and boutique). The product description for the mall even contained the phrase, "The more your Pixel Chix gal works, the more she has to spend in the mall". The work they referred to was the babysitting scenario. The stereotypes of feminine domesticity and an inherent love for shopping are thus combined.



The message sent by the majority of the toys I looked at served to reinforce many widely-held beliefs about what girls like, what they focus on, and how they interact. The third best-selling toy for this age group of girls was the "Hannah Montana Girl Talk" game, a board game version of truth or dare. There were also other games that centered on the telling of secrets and the disclosure of information about oneself. These are not necessarily bad things, but they are decidedly feminine as I can recall no male equivalent to games of this sort. As Nancy Henley and Jo Freeman note, "Female socialization encourages generally greater expression of emotion than does male socialization" (87). Thus, girls are taught at a young age that being emotionally open is part of being a girl. Girls are pitched these ideas not only as individuals but as a group. Toys are one of the main ways children interact with one another. So when young girls are interacting with one another by playing games that play up certain ideas about their role in the world as girls, they are learning that this is what will be expected of them by society at large.



Thus toys are a way for society to make sure children know exactly what their roles are in their respective gender. The age of the girl I was supposed to be shopping for illustrates the young age at which these gender roles are already being enforced. Susan Jane Gilman states that "dolls often give children their first lessons in what a society considers valuable" (74). Applying this theory to toys in general, it is easy to see how if children take their cues for what their adolescent and adult lives will be like from the toys they play with they will no doubt fit into certain gender stereotypes. An ideology is, according to Stuart Hall, "those images, concepts, and premises which provide the framework through which we represent, interpret, understand, and 'make sense' of some aspect of social existence" (89). By catering to a certain ideology, toy manufacturers teach young girls to understand the world in a certain way. Though not all the toys I encountered directly reinforced some stereotype about women, many of them did. Among the stereotypes underlying the toys being sold to girls of this age group were the idea that the color pink, shopping, domestic settings (such as the "Barbie Totally Real House Playset, pictured right), a preoccupation with appearance, and a tendency to divulge secrets are all "feminine" traits. Though many girls no doubt enjoy playing with these toys, the lack of differentiation or deviation from these general themes is evidence of an ideology that assumes that young girls only want to play with these types of toys, while at the same time teaching those same girls that this is what they're "supposed" to enjoy.









REFERENCES



Barbie Forever Barbie Totally Real House Playset. 31 September 2007. <http://www.amazon.com/Barbie-Forever-Totally-House-%09Playset/dp/B000BCEJI6/ref=sr_1_15/103-7324622-2279828?ie=UTF8&s=toys-and-games&qid=1191293468&sr=1-15>.



Barbie Girls - Pink. 31 September 2007. <http://www.amazon.com/Mattel-L2936-Barbie-Girls-Pink/dp/B000PD73P2/ref=sr_1_2/103-7324622->.



Bratz P4F Sasha. 31 September 2007. <http://www.amazon.com/MGA-333821-Bratz-P4F-Sasha/dp/B000EPFEZW/ref=sr_1_39/103-7324622-2279828?%09ie=UTF8&s=toys-and-games&qid=1191296406&sr=1-39>.



Gilman, Susan Jane. "Klaus Barbie, and Other Dolls I'd Like to See." Women: Images and Realities. Ed. Amy Kesselman, Lily D. McNair, Nancy Schniedewind. New York: McGraw Hill, 2003. 72-75.



Hall, Stuart. "The Whites of Their Eyes: Racist Ideologies and the Media." Gender, Race, and Class in Media. Ed. Gail Dines and Jean M. Humez. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications, 2003. 89-93.



Henley, Nancy and Jo Freeman. "The Sexual Politics of Interpersonal Behavior." Women: Images and Realities. Ed. Amy Kesselman, Lily D. McNair, Nancy Schniedewind. New York: McGraw Hill, 2003. 84-92.



Pixel Chix - Love 2 Shop Mall: Boutique/Foodcourt. "Product Features". 31 September 2007. <http://www.amazon.com/Pixel-Chix-Love-Boutique-%09Court/dp/B000FNNZDG/ref=pd_sim_t_shvl_title_1/103-7324622-2279828?ie=UTF8&qid=1191298467&sr=1-41>.

21 comments:

EGREGIUS said...

A very interesting post!
I love toys.
fr.

rozzie bear said...

Hey! Nice work! I really liked how you incorporated quotes about how ideologies play a role in society, and I think your discussion about how girls are taught to fit into certain roles was really well supported and thoughtfully written. I just had a few suggestions for deepening your analysis. You focused on toys that emphasized “feminine” traits such as being emotionally open or fashion conscious. Why do you think so many toys support this hegemonic view? What does it say about what we as a society value? You may want to discuss how these messages are not only evident in toys but teen mags as well, showing the progression and reinforcement of “what society wants” in a woman as the little girl in your blog grows up (and speaking of hegemony, Lull’s piece on it would really be a great resource here). Also, did you see any “gender neutral” toys or toys that offered different messages to girls other than the messages you saw? Toys like this are hard to find, if they even exist. What messages would be better to give to young girls? How could the mainstream themes be counteracted? What kind of skills/knowledge/opportunities would better serve girls? There are obviously harmful influences on toy shelves, but if changes are to be made we have to think about what these influences are and what we’d rather say. There are no easy answers for any of these questions, but thinking about them may give all of us a deeper understanding of the genderization of children.

But seriously? Good job! :)

Jessie said...

Your post is quite well written and makes excellent use of the quotes from the course readings. The comments Roz made are extremely similar to my own thoughts on your post. Try to deepen your analysis by introducing the concept of the ideological framework at the beginning of the paper. It will help you assert some of your existing ideas in a more meaningful way to support your theis.

Nissa said...

People should read this.

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!

Anonymous said...

Browse Around This Website

Look into my homepage :: attorney lead generation
Here is my weblog ... seo for attorneys

Anonymous said...

The military footwear a pace forward and in the successful route.


Feel free to visit my page leads for lawyers
Also visit my weblog ... lawyer search engine optimization

Anonymous said...

I've been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or blog posts in this sort of area . Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this website. Studying this information So i'm satisfied to exhibit that I have an incredibly good
uncanny feeling I discovered exactly what I needed.

I such a lot for sure will make sure to do not put out of your mind this web site and give it
a look regularly.

my web-site - best registry cleaner

Anonymous said...

Hello There. I discovered your weblog the use of msn. This is a really neatly written article.
I will make sure to bookmark it and come back to learn extra of your useful info.
Thanks for the post. I'll definitely return.

my blog post; similar resource site

Anonymous said...

It's truly very complex in this active life to listen news on TV, therefore I simply use internet for that purpose, and obtain the hottest news.

Also visit my blog post :: www.sssmep.cz Additional Info additional reading Check Out www.sssmep.cz Check This Out Click at www.sssmep.cz Click At this website click for source Click Here Click In this article Click on www.sssmep.cz Click On this page Clicking Here Continue Continue Reading Continued Continuing Discover More Discover More Here Extra resources Find Out More Full Article Full Content Full Document Full Guide Full Piece of writing Full Post Full Posting Full Record Full Report Full Review Full Statement Full Survey Full Write-up Get More Info Get More Information Get the facts Go At this site Go Here Going at www.sssmep.cz Going At this website Going Here Going in www.sssmep.cz Going In this article Going Listed here Going On this page Going On this site Going to www.sssmep.cz helpful hints helpful resources Home Page homepage home-page keep reading Learn Additional Learn Additional Here Learn Alot more Learn Alot more Here Learn Even more Learn Even more Here Learn More Learn More Here link linked internet page linked internet site linked resource site linked site linked web page linked web site linked webpage linked website linked web-site Look At This main page more More about the author More Bonuses More Help more helpful hints More hints More Info More Information More Information and facts More inspiring ideas More Material More methods more resources More Signup bonuses More suggestions More Support More Tips next page Ongoing Our site our website please click Read www.sssmep.cz Read A great deal more Read A lot more Read Alot more Read Even more Read Far more Read Full Article Read Full Report Read More More On this page Read read on Read Significantly more Read the Full Article Read the Full Content Read the Full Document Read the Full Guide Read the Full Piece of writing Read the Full Post Read the Full Posting Read the Full Report Read the Full Write-up Read This here Here related internet page related resource site Related Site related web page related web site related webpage related website related web-site relevant internet page relevant internet site relevant resource site relevant site relevant web page relevant web site relevant webpage relevant website relevant web-site resource for this article resources similar internet page similar internet site similar resource site similar site similar web page similar web site similar webpage similar website similar web-site simply click www.sssmep.cz source source for this article sources supplemental resources This Internet page This Internet site This Resource site This Site This Web page This Web site This Webpage this website This Web-site Visit www.sssmep.cz Visit Website web page web site webpage website

Anonymous said...

Why users still make use of to read news papers when in this technological globe everything is available on web?


my weblog - npworldview.blogspot.com

Anonymous said...



my web site ... watch elementary online hd

Anonymous said...

It not only does it look nice in my house, but the easy management and great video gaming experience that
I am getting (without any lag at all) is simply too awesome.
Because most routers are made from the same components, the only real difference in functionality comes from the firmware that
is installed by the factory. It supports WPS (Wi - Fi Protected Setup) and supports
Cisco CCX.

My weblog; where to buy ASUS RT-N66U

Anonymous said...

A couple of years ago, few could ever imagine the impact the My - Space epoch would place on other outlets that followed it'Facebook, Google+,
Twitter and the newest player, Pinterest. hen, eine kulturell konfrontiert
kulinarisches Erleben sind, wissen wir nicht erblicken wollen, was Sie je dasjenige Mittagessen
mit. Scrolling through existing photo vines and photos is done by swiping your i - Phone's screen either to the left or right.
You can understand from them and create your very own
exceptional way of cataloging your images or photographs and unit distinct ways by means of which you can
share them with your viewers. Their major challengers have
been created for the most part seeing that extension cords of the desktop computer computer.


My site - instagram like bot for mac

Anonymous said...

Great beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend
your web site, how can i subscribe for a blog website?

The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit
acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright
clear concept

Feel free to surf to my homepage IC Projman

Anonymous said...

Inspect the prospect gym and see if it is in keeping with your standards.

However, look at reality and be rational about your goals,
so that you stay motivated. It had become more and
more evident by the 1920s and1930s that health
and the development of the body were connected very closely (Schwarzenegger 11).


Here is my web site: website ()

Anonymous said...

Hello there! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form?
I'm using the same blog platform as yours and I'm having trouble finding
one? Thanks a lot!

Feel free to surf to my web page - erc viet nam

Anonymous said...

Ship items to your pals for theirs, and have them send you points at the same time.

We're going to be dividing most of your drive below, and that means that
data issues are feasible.

Here is my weblog; whatsapp for pc (wiki.web-univer.su)

Anonymous said...

The othеr dɑy, while I was at work, my sister stole
my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a 25 foot drop,
jսst so she can be a youtube sensation.
My iPaɗ is now ƅroken and she has 83 ѵiews.
I know this is completely off topiс but I had to shаre it wіth someone!


My web Ьlog :: Ford Ranger For sale

Anonymous said...

Treɑting diabetes natuгally is often a 'touchy' subject.
Accоrding to the CTV article, some scientists in Boston scientists have been testing bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BSG), a vacсine used
for mοre than eight decades to prevent tuberculosis, on people with Type 1 diabetеs, also callеd juvenile diabetes.
The Truth is your doctor doeѕn't know about tҺis remedy because mߋst
of them simply don't have time to keep up оn natսгal solutions.


Feel free to surf to my wеb pagе Reveгtir La DiaƄetes PDF Descargar (http://revertirladiabetes-pdfdescargar.blogspot.com)

Anonymous said...

It'ѕ difficult to find well-informed people for thіs topic, but you seem like
you know whаt you're talking aƅout! Thanks

Also visit my web blog - і want to who can helр me clear
սp my credit report - ,